Didn't Show Up. Still Won.

HOW NOT TO PROVE A COMMON LAW TRADEMARK
Wizard Labs Inc. v. Nanci Nette, FORUM, Claim: FA2608002240604
In domain name cases, the Complainant has to prove that it has a registered trademark, but, if not, it must prove an unregistered or common law trademark, which the Complainant in this case tried to do, sort of. But it failed.
Wizard Labs Inc. is in computer software design. The domain name was <wizardlabs.us>.
The case it put forward to prove its alleged common law trademark was very weak, amounting to the fact that it had changed its name to WIZARD LABS Inc and it also produced one invoice that it had sent out. This was obviously not good enough, as it really should have tried to produce evidence that the name had in fact been used in business and had been recognised as such in the marketplace. Good evidence that often wins the day on this issue is evidence of extensive use of the word in the market, trade publications, advertising and suchlike. That sort of evidence was absent in this case.
Evidence of advertising, publicity, awards, surveys, commentary, branding, websites and other evidence is usually there in abundance, if only you will look for it. It is obviously worth the effort to find it and use it.
It may well decide whether the claim will be won or lost.
The decision in this case was commendably brief and to the point. And it was correct. Evidence like the flimsy evidence relied on was clearly not enough.
The case is Wizard Labs Inc. v. Nanci Nette, FORUM, Claim: FA2608002240604 and you may read it at https://www.adrforum.com/DomainDecisions/2240604.htm.




Comments