Flipping Domains Is Fair Game

3-MEMBER PANEL ASKS: IS SELLING A DOMAIN NAME LEGITIMATE?
Xano, Inc. v. Patrick Robalewski
This case concerns the frequent practice of registering a domain name and then putting it up for sale. Indeed, the owner of the domain name may never have intended to use it for any purpose other than to sell it. This can be legitimate and above board, depending of course on the circumstances. This case is one where it was quite legitimate.
The Complainant had a trademark for XANO registered for purposes connected with the web.
The Respondent registered the domain name <xano.ai>, well after the Complainant had registered its XANO trademark. It resolved to a website putting it up for sale for $300,000 and promoted it for AI purposes. As the Complainant’s own website at www.xano.com showed its own AI activities, this showed that there was a prima facie case that the Respondent did not have a right or legitimate interest in the <xano.ai> domain name it was trying to sell.
But the Respondent could still try to prove that it had such a right or legitimate interest. It did this by showing that it was a domain name investor and that it had some similar domain names to the one in dispute which were also in the “.ai” field. It was able therefore to show that it was using <xano.ai> for a bona fide offering of goods or services, namely by putting it up for sale to the public. That case was strengthened by the fact that, yes, the Complainant had a XANO trademark, but other trademark registrants have the same trademark and there was nothing to show that the Respondent was aiming at the Complainant’s XANO. The Respondent had therefore proved its point and the Panel found that it had a right or legitimate interest in the domain name.
Moreover, the same facts showed that the Respondent had not registered or used <xano.ai> in bad faith.
The Complainant therefore lost, but had it also engaged in Reverse Domain Name Hijacking? No. In all the circumstances it had a reasonable and good-faith belief that it could succeed and it was therefore justified in starting the proceeding. After all, the domain name was identical to its trademark and the Complainant had a reasonable belief that its trademark was being targeted. The Complainant therefore had a reasonable case for making the case. The trouble was: it had failed.
The case, which was a claim before a 3-member Panel, is Xano, Inc. v. Patrick Robalewski, FORUM, Claim Number: FA2608002237082 and you can read the decision at https://www.adrforum.com/DomainDecisions/2237082.htm.




Comments