You Can't Backdate Bad Faith

NO BAD FAITH REGISTRATION
There is sometimes a quick and very clear ground for rejecting an allegation that a domain name was registered in bad faith.
A recent case that illustrates this was the FORUM decision in Wil Wes Rappaport v. Joseph Todd / Shadow Mountain Holdings, LLC. The Complainant, Wil Wes Rappaport, owns the trademark BVOS; the Respondent, Shadow Mountain Holdings, LLC, is a business valuation and M&A firm that held the domain name. In that case, the domain name in dispute, <bvos.com>, was created on October 22, 1997 and the Respondent acquired it on April 27, 2023. Both of these events occurred before the Complainant (that makes clothing like T-shirts) acquired its trademark and even before it had applied for the trademark, which was on May 19, 2023. Thus, it was impossible for the domain to have been registered in bad faith, even if it was subsequently used in bad faith.
In any case, and consistent with that conclusion, the domain name was a common four-letter acronym with several meanings, a plausible one of which was reasonably open to the Respondent to use in its business.
Even had the Complainant overcome this problem, there was no bad faith use as, although the Respondent had put the domain name up for sale on Sedo, you could not say that there had been any targeting of the Complainant.
A handy decision to note.
The decision was Wil Wes Rappaport v. Joseph Todd / Shadow Mountain Holdings, LLC, FORUM Claim Number: FA2608002237495, which you may read at https://www.adrforum.com/DomainDecisions/2237495.htm




Comments